Why Xavi Hernández and José Mourinho Could Be the Wrong Fit for Newcastle United — And the Key Reasons Behind It

Newcastle knows he must deliver a strong finish to the season after stopped short of offering any long-term guarantees about his future at .

When asked about Howe’s position, Hopkinson avoided firm assurances, instead stressing that the club’s full attention is on the final seven fixtures and the push to secure European qualification.

Currently sitting 12th in the table, Newcastle have endured an inconsistent campaign, prompting some fans to question whether Howe is the right figure to take the club forward. Hopkinson’s cautious stance has only fueled further uncertainty.

As a result, speculation is growing over potential replacements should Howe depart, with several high-profile names linked to the role at St James’ Park.

One of those mentioned is , who previously managed in the Saudi Pro League before guiding to a La Liga title. Although he has been out of work since leaving the club in 2024, bookmakers have still listed him among the contenders.

Former Newcastle winger believes Xavi would bring excitement but questions whether his managerial experience is sufficient. He suggested fans would be cautious, wanting to see a clear style of play and direction before fully backing him. Waddle also doubts Xavi would be a top choice if the club decides to make a change, adding that the Spaniard would need to prove himself—especially without any experience.

Another name linked is , who has often spoken fondly of Newcastle due to his connection with . Reports in Portugal have suggested a possible return to England, but sources close to the club’s ownership have dismissed the idea.

Waddle acknowledged Mourinho’s achievements but argued that his pragmatic, results-driven style might not suit Newcastle’s identity. He pointed out that supporters traditionally favor attacking, entertaining football, recalling managers like and Robson who embraced a front-foot approach.

In his view, even consistent wins might not be enough if the style of play fails to excite the fanbase—something he believes could make Mourinho a difficult fit on Tyneside.