Keith Hackett instantly reacts to footage of Everton penalty controversy vs Burnley

Everton were left frustrated after a late penalty appeal was waved away during their goalless draw with Burnley on Saturday.

The controversial moment came when Tyler Dibling’s effort was blocked by Jaidon Anthony inside the box.

As the Burnley player charged down the shot, the ball appeared to strike his arm, but referee Craig Pawson declined to award a penalty, much to the frustration of David Moyes and his players at Turf Moor on 27 December.

Although the Premier League later issued a statement defending the on-field decision, former PGMOL chief Keith Hackett strongly disagreed with the explanation.

Hackett criticises penalty decision

Speaking exclusively to Goodison News, Hackett made his stance clear, insisting Everton should have been given a spot-kick.

“The player has his arm extended away from his body and had time to withdraw it given the distance the ball travelled,” Hackett said. “For me, this was handball and a penalty should have been awarded.”

His comments will only add to Moyes’ growing frustration over the number of decisions that have gone against Everton this season.

Everton urged to confront PGMOL again

The Toffees have endured a string of controversial calls, and pressure is mounting for the club to seek further clarification from the PGMOL.

Moyes was already unhappy with the lack of communication following last week’s incident against Arsenal, where the Gunners were awarded a penalty while Everton were denied one in similar circumstances.

Hackett has previously criticised Howard Webb for his silence on such matters, and many feel the Everton boss must once again demand answers from the refereeing body.

The club previously met with the PGMOL earlier this season after Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall was suspended for accumulating five yellow cards — at least one of which was considered questionable.

With decisions continuing to go against them, Everton believe accountability is required.

These calls have a direct impact on results, league position, and potentially even qualification for European football — and the lack of transparency from officials is becoming increasingly difficult to accept.