James McFadden baffled by Stuart Findlay penalty controversy in Rangers vs Hearts – ‘There’s no doubt’

James McFadden baffled by Stuart Findlay penalty controversy in Rangers vs Hearts – ‘There’s no doubt’

Stuart Findlay was perhaps lucky to escape punishment during ’ 4–2 victory over on Sunday, a result that kept the Light Blues firmly in the Scottish Premiership title race.

The Govan side went into the clash under added pressure after snatched a dramatic late winner to edge past 3–2, raising the stakes before kick-off. Rangers responded by reclaiming top spot, but only after a tense and eventful afternoon against ’ men.

Despite the scoreline, the match could have been far more comfortable for the hosts had they been awarded a penalty early on. Rangers twice found themselves behind, making their eventual triumph all the more hard-earned.

Once again, proved decisive on a big occasion. The forward struck a superb hat-trick, sealing the win with his third goal after a driving run from Djeidi Gassama created the opening for him to finish clinically. His goals were the difference between settling for a point and taking all three at Ibrox.

However, Chermiti could have completed his treble much earlier. Findlay appeared to handle the ball after heading it onto his own arm inside the penalty area, but referee waved play on. The incident was checked by VAR, yet the on-field decision stood, much to the disbelief of former Scotland striker , speaking live on .

“It looked to me as if he headed it onto his arm,” McFadden said. “He’s got loads of space, and there’s no doubt for me that the ball comes off his head onto his hand.”

In the end, that moment became irrelevant thanks to Chermiti’s ruthless finishing. While Rangers may have felt unfortunate not to receive a spot-kick—one that might have been given on another day—they ensured there would be no lingering controversy by taking control themselves.

Had the result gone the other way, questions would likely have been asked of and his side regarding the decision. But with three vital points secured, Rangers will care little about what might have been as they continue their push at the top of the table.